
It is not easy to write a paper on a book that you have not finished formulating your opinion on. Neil Cole has painted a picture of church that is in stark contrast to the kind of churches I got saved in, grew up in, got trained in, and served in. There is much in the book that I agree with but most of what I think of as the best parts have nothing to do with the organic churches being so small and reproducible but rather points that would apply to any kind of church.
I think he does a good job of clearly showing some of the biggest failings in the institutional church. He says things like “In many of the churches in the West, ministry is done for Jesus, but not by Jesus…” or “Unfortunately, in most churches in the Western world the presence of the pastor is more noticeable than the presence of Jesus.” He mentions that in a lot of churches when the people know the pastor will be out the attendance drops. Another quote I like is: “our current systems are perfectly designed to produce the results we are now seeing.” He has a lot to say throughout the book noting the areas where the Western church is not right and I think he has great insight into many of those things.
I like his definition of the church. Neil quickly sets out to define church as such: The presence of Jesus among His people called out as a spiritual family to pursue His mission on this planet. This is simple and yet, incomplete but if you assume the rest of the Biblical requirements, I like it. He also talks about the DNA of the church and the three things all churches must have. DNA is Divine truth, Nurturing relationships, and Apostolic mission.
My favorite part was about the different kinds of soil in the parable where Jesus tells about the sower. In this section he makes many good points about ministry. He talks about the mistake we have made in accommodating bad soil in our churches and how it leads to an audience of consumers shopping for the best “services” which requires them to make little or no effort. Too often attendance equals good standing in our churches… even people who are totally uncommitted to the Kingdom that are distracted by the deceitfulness of riches and the desire for other things can still be a member of our church. He encourages us instead of investing in bad soil to invest everything into the few that will bear fruit. “Life is too short….to babysit fruitless people.” One of my favorite lines in the book is when he says that "bad people (drug addicts, prostitutes, ect.) make good soil because there is a lot of fertilizer in their lives." He goes on to say that good soil can be found in bad people (sinners), poor people, young people, seekers, uneducated and powerless people. I agree with this statement and want to make my life about ministering to these kinds of people.
I love the emphasis on evangelism, community, confession, and reading large amounts of scripture and I hope to have these elements in any church that I plant. But In his model of the organic church I was left wondering about elders and authority, tithing, laying on of hands too hastily in new converts. This book is full of good one liners and views on ministry and church planting…but the best materiel does not seem exclusive to home churches…and I think that was supposed to be the point.